Hall of Shame: Texas Leads Nation in DNA Exonerations
By: Houston Criminal Attorney John Floyd and Paralegal Billy Sinclair
That the Houston City Police Department’s Crime Lab was a lawless, rogue unit serving the “convict at any costs” philosophy of the Harris County District Attorney’s Office during the Johnny Holmes and Charles “Chuck” Rosenthal administrations, between 1980 and 2005, is no longer a subject of serious debate. Dozens, possibly hundreds, of innocent people—mostly poor minorities charged with homicides or sex crimes—were railroaded off to Texas prisons based on fabricated (or at best faulty) forensic evidence supplied by the Crime Lab and/or due to mistaken identification secured to corrupt pretrial photo lineup procedures.
On June 13, 2007, former U.S. Justice Department Inspector Michael Bromwich issued a 400-page report that concluded the crime lab’s DNA and serology departments had made hundreds of “serious and pervasive” mistakes in homicide and sexual assault cases. Bromwich two-year investigation examined more than 3500 cases processed by the crime lab over the previous quarter century. 135 of those were DNA cases handled by the crime lab between 1992 and 2002, Bromwich’s investigators found “major issues” in 43 of those cases, and, even more disturbing, found “major issues” in 4 of the 18 death penalty cases it examined.
Before Bromwich initiated his investigation, and following a 2002 “audit” of the crime lab ordered by city officials, two Harris County criminal defendants were ordered released by local courts after it was determined that the crime lab’s false forensic evidence had resulted in their wrongful rape convictions. George Rodriquez was released in 2004 after serving 17 years in the Texas prison system for kidnapping and rape. A Harris County federal jury awarded him $5 million this past June based on the city’s “deliberate indifference” to the recurring problems at the crime lab. In 2003 Josiah Sutton was released after serving 4 ½ years for a rape conviction after DNA tests discredited forensic tests performed by the crime lab. The following year Gov. Rick Perry granted a “full pardon” to Sutton.
Since the June 2007 release of the Bromwich report, four additional Harris County criminal defendants have been ordered released by local courts after it was determined they had been wrongfully convicted of sex offenses. The first was Ronald Gene Taylor who was released in October 2007 after serving 14 years for a rape conviction. DNA evidence—semen on the rape victim’s bed sheet which had not been tested by the crime lab—revealed that the semen belonged to another man who had a history of violent sexual assaults. (more…)
